Best Locking Mailbox Reviews and Buying Guide 2018

    Shares
    Best Locking Mailbox

    These days, it seems like you can’t go anywhere without running into the term “identity theft.” As the fastest growing crime in the world, it’s likely that you will become victim to it at some point in your life.

    Unfortunately, one of the easiest and most efficient ways for thieves to access your personal information is through the mail. Although bills and junk mail may seem innocuous to you, it can contain vital data that can threaten your identity.

    Fortunately, with the best locking mailboxes, you can stop thieves in their tracks. Not only will these units protect your information, but you won’t have to worry about packages and other valuables getting stolen as well.

    If you’re concerned about the safety and security of your mail, then you want to get one of these locking mailboxes as soon as possible. Don’t wait until you become a victim. Be proactive and give yourself peace of mind. Let’s see what these products can do for you

    Comparison of Locking Mailboxes

    Recommended 6 Best Locking Mailbox Reviews

    1. Mail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Locking Security Mailbox

    When trying to find the right locking mailbox, one brand is synonymous with this kind of security. Mail Boss products are high-quality and built to last, so you can rest easy knowing that your mail is kept safe inside one of these units. We’re going to see a lot of Mail Boss on this list, but let’s see what the Mail Manager has to offer.

    First of all, the construction of this box is top notch. It’s made of galvanized welded steel, and it comes with a robust powder coated finish. The coating is there to help prevent rust and weather damage, and it gives the whole thing a polished and beautiful appearance. Just because you’re securing your packages doesn’t mean that the device can’t look good in the process.

    As far as security goes, the Mail Manager has a few critical features that ensure that thieves won’t be able to get inside. The door mechanism uses a baffle, which keeps the contents separated as you load mail into it. This feature is there to prevent fishing, which is when someone reaches into the box to access its contents. If you’re not familiar with how this works, it’s the same as on every USPS mailbox you can find.

    The other thing that keeps your mail secure is the anti-pry locking mechanism. It’s made of durable stainless steel and ensures that thieves won’t be able to pop the lock off with a crowbar or other similar device. Although these locks can’t prevent access 100% of the time, it is a sufficient deterrent. Only the most hardcore thieves will be able to penetrate these defenses, and chances are that your mail is not worth the extra effort.

    When it comes to outgoing mail, this box comes with a clip so that you can keep it inside the baffle, rather than outside in plain view. Since theft works both ways, having your outgoing letters and packages concealed adds another layer of protection and peace of mind. The only downside is that you have limited space in which to hold anything.

    Mail Boss is so confident in its products that the Mail Manager comes with a limited lifetime warranty against defects or pre-existing damage. To make mounting and installation easier for you, instructions are included with the box, as well as three keys.

    Finally, this box comes in one of four colors, so you are sure to find one that fits the style and aesthetic of your home.

    Pros

    • check
      Approved by the USPS
    • check
      Durable galvanized welded steel construction
    • check
      Sleek powder-coated finish
    • check
      Four color options available
    • check
      Innovative baffle door prevents fishing
    • check
      Anti-pry mechanism for added safety
    • check
      Built-in flag on the side
    • check
      Three keys provided for convenience
    • check
      Concealed outgoing mail clip
    • check
      Mounting instructions included
    • check
      Limited lifetime warranty

    Cons

    • Can be difficult to get key replacements
    • Outgoing mail clip is limited in size

    2. Architectural Mailboxes 6200B-10 Oasis Classic Locking Post Mount Parcel Mailbox

    These days, ordering packages online has become second nature. Unfortunately, thieves know this, and they take advantage of unattended boxes that are sitting on your doorstep. With most locking mailboxes, the door is too small to accept these items, which means that all of your online orders can be at risk.

    Thankfully, the Oasis Mailbox from Architectural Mailboxes is the perfect accessory for your home. It’s larger design allows you to accept most small to medium-sized packages without risking the safety and security of their contents.

    Once again, protecting your mail is a baffle door that ensures that no one can reach inside and grab anything. The baffle is spacious to allow for boxes as well as letters, so you won’t miss anything that gets delivered (unless it’s massive).

    The construction of this box is superb, with galvanized steel components and a weather-resistant design. To make things even better for you and your mail, this model also comes with rubber gaskets on the sides to ensure that water doesn’t leak in by accident. If you live in a rainy climate, this box is a must.

    Protecting your contents is a thick locking mechanism that won’t pry open easily. As we mentioned with the Mail Manager, no lock is 100% secure, but this one will prevent all but the most ardent thieves from breaking in.

    Other features that you can expect from the Oasis include a built-in mail flag to let you know when the mailman has stopped by, easy mounting instructions that allow you to get your box up and ready to go in no time, and two keys so that you always have access to your packages.

    Also, as with most locking mailboxes, this unit comes with a limited lifetime warranty against defects or damage.

    Pros

    • check
      Larger design can accept parcels and letters
    • check
      Durable galvanized steel construction
    • check
      Rubber seals prevent moisture and water
    • check
      Corrosion-resistant materials
    • check
      Baffle door prevents fishing
    • check
      Anti-pry locking mechanism
    • check
      Built-in mail flag
    • check
      Pre-drilled holes for easier installation
    • check
      Can be mounted to pole or column
    • check
      Weather-resistant design
    • check
      Two keys provided for convenience
    • check
      Limited lifetime warranty

    Cons

    • Keys can be difficult to replace
    • Baffle may not prevent all fishing attempts

    3. Epoch 7106 MailBoss Curbside Locking Mailbox, Black

    Securing your mail is serious business, but most locking mailboxes have a bit of a disadvantage when it comes to outgoing materials. In most cases, you either have to clip the mail to the side of the box, or place it in the door and hope that it doesn’t get stolen. The other issue is that you don’t have that much space to put anything, so if you have to send a package or a lot of envelopes, you are out of luck.

    With the Epoch Mailbox from Mail Boss, however, these problems are minimized. Unlike the Mail Manager above, this unit has a separate slot for outgoing mail. Best of all, the incoming slot is still protected by a baffle door, so you don’t have to worry about fishing. If you send a lot of mail, this is the box to get.

     As with all Mail Boss models, this one is made of high-quality materials. The hinges are stainless steel, and the sides are constructed of galvanized steel. A powder coating prevents rust and water damage and ensures that this box will last for years.

    Another excellent feature that comes with the Epoch is the Fast-Trak mounting plate. In many cases, you need an expert to help you get your mailbox secured properly, but that’s not an issue with this model. Using the plate, you should be able to get it up onto a pole or installed on a column in less time than you might think.

    If you want to add some practicality to this mailbox, it also comes with reflective address stickers. This allows you to make it easier to spot for your mailman so that he or she doesn’t miss the box or deliver to the wrong house.

    Other features of this unit include three keys for your convenience, a built-in mail flag, and four different color options. Matching the Epoch to the style of your home has never been easier. Also, it comes with a limited lifetime warranty against defects.

    Pros

    • check
      Durable galvanized steel construction
    • check
      Stainless steel hinges
    • check
      Weather-resistant design
    • check
      Built-in mail flag
    • check
      Anti-pry locking mechanism
    • check
      Baffle door prevents fishing
    • check
      Fast-trak mounting plate for easy installation
    • check
      Three keys provided for convenience
    • check
      Four color options available
    • check
      Reflective house number stickers included
    • check
      Separate slots for outgoing and incoming mail
    • check
      Limited lifetime warranty

    Cons

    • In rare cases, the keys may not work and have to be replaced
    • Hinges might be susceptible to rust over time

    4. Gibraltar Mailsafe Medium Capacity Wall-Mount Mailbox

    When it comes to mail security, there is something of a sliding scale of protection. So far, we’ve been looking at models that are on the top end of the spectrum. However, if you aren’t as paranoid about your mail getting stolen, or you just want something more cost-effective and easy to install, then this unit from Gibraltar Mailboxes may be a better option.

    Unlike the other boxes we’ve seen thus far, this one is made of thick aluminum instead of steel. This ensures that the whole thing isn’t as heavy or as bulky, making it easier to attach to the side of your house or mail post. However, the downside is that it’s easier to break into, so keep that in mind.

    Overall, this box is perfect for anyone who lives in a safe neighborhood but still wants some added security. The locking mechanism ensures that your mail stays safe from prying hands. And the cam lock door helps keep them out as well. It’s not as secure as a baffle, but it’s more than sufficient for any opportunists looking for a score. 

    Pros

    • check
      Compact size
    • check
      Durable metal and aluminum construction
    • check
      Built-in mail flag
    • check
      Cam lock door prevents theft
    • check
      Black or white design
    • check
      Compartmentalized delivery system
    • check
      Two keys provided for convenience
    • check
      Lightweight and easy to install

    Cons

    • Not as durable as steel models
    • Not designed for receiving packages

    5. Step2 531700 MailMaster StoreMore Mailbox

    When picking out the right locking mailbox for your home, style and appearance can make a huge difference. Usually, the most secure models are also the least aesthetically pleasing. They can seem so utilitarian that they almost invite scrutiny and attempts from thieves.

    Thus, if you want a locking mailbox that adds some flair to your home while keeping your mail safe, then this model from Step2 is an ideal choice. It has the appearance of a stone pillar, which creates a sense of elegance and refinement for your front yard.

    One thing to keep in mind when picking this unit out is that it’s made of plastic. As such, it won’t prevent thieves as well as galvanized steel, but it will keep opportunistic criminals at bay. So, if you’re trying to get the best protection, you might want to look elsewhere.

    What we like about this mailbox is that the stone pillar is not just for appearances. It also doubles as storage for your packages, which means that you can accept a lot more than you could with any of the other units on this list. Best of all, you can access the top and the bottom separately, making it even more convenient.

    But what if you don’t need all that space for your mail? Well, in that case, you can use the false bottom that comes with the box so that everything stays in the top portion. However, this section is easier to access, so keep that in mind. In some instances, it might be better to allow everything to fall down so that no one can go fishing for personal information.

    Overall, if style is just as vital to you as security, then you will appreciate what the MailMaster StoreBox has to offer. Just make sure that you have professional installation so that it stays stable on the ground.

    Pros

    • check
      Extra large mailbox fits packages and letters
    • check
      Elegant faux stone pillar design
    • check
      Top and bottom lock for added protection
    • check
      Removable floor separates top and bottom
    • check
      Front and rear access for convenience
    • check
      Weather-resistant materials
    • check
      Two keys provided
    • check
      Address numbers included
    • check
      Built-in mail flag

    Cons

    • Mounting can be tricky
    • Plastic is not as durable as steel models
    • Opening is not baffled, so fishing is possible

    6. Mail Boss Package Master Best Security Mailbox

    Although the size of the MailMaster above was an excellent feature, the lack of high-quality security features is kind of a downside. Thus, if you want to be able to accept most of your packages without worry, then you will want to get something like the Package Master from Mail Boss.

    This is the largest and most secure locking mailbox that we’ve seen, which makes it perfect for the avid at-home shopper. If you find yourself buying things online on a regular basis, then this is the box for you.

    Because it’s from Mail Boss, you know that your contents will be safe and secure from theft. The large baffle door allows packages of all sizes to be dropped off with ease. Also, it provides you with ample space for your outgoing mail as well. Fishing is not an option with this door, so you can have peace of mind.

    The construction of this box is top-notch as well, as it’s made of heavy-duty galvanized steel. It comes in one of four colors, and it has a powder coating to protect against rust and water damage. As with all Mail Boss products, this box has a limited lifetime warranty against defects.

    Other features that come with the Package Master include an anti-pry locking mechanism, a Fast-Trak mounting plate for easy installation, and address numbers for better visibility on your street. Also, it comes with three keys and a built-in mail flag for your convenience.

    Pros

    • check
      Extra large capacity for packages
    • check
      Durable galvanized steel construction
    • check
      Four color options available
    • check
      Easy to mount and install
    • check
      Baffled door prevents fishing
    • check
      Anti-pry locking mechanism
    • check
      Powder coated for weather resistance
    • check
      Three keys included for convenience
    • check
      Address numbers provided
    • check
      Built-in mail flag
    • check
      Limited lifetime warranty

    Cons

    • In rare cases, it may arrive damaged
    • Outgoing mail clip is limited in size

    How to Choose the ​Best Security Mailbox

    Size

    Before you worry about anything else, it’s imperative that you make sure that your locking mailbox will be able to hold everything that it should. If you buy a lot of items online, then you want to have a model that can fit all of your deliveries with ease. Otherwise, they will be left out for thieves, which kind of defeats the purpose of having a locking mailbox in the first place.

    The other thing to consider with regards to size is how well it will fit in your current setup. For example, if you have to mount it to a mailbox column, will it work? Similarly, if you use a wooden post, will it be too bulky or heavy?

    Thus, you want to check the dimensions and do some measurements before you pull the trigger on any of these models. Taking the time to do this will ensure that you don’t have to take it back after the fact.

    Material

    Since security is the priority with these products, you have to be sure that it can repel any theft attempts. For the best results, we highly recommend galvanized or stainless steel. This material will not only hold up better against break-ins, but it will resist weather and water damage as well.

    Other options for these products include plastic or aluminum. These are ideal if you’re not as concerned with security since they can be broken into more easily. The other benefit of choosing a material like plastic is that it’s lighter and easier to install, and it won’t rust or degrade as quickly over time. Even treated galvanized steel will start to rust after a few years, but plastic will always stay in prime condition.

    Door Mechanism

    As we’ve seen on this list, baffle doors are by far the best choice when trying to protect your mail. The reason that these are ideal is that they prevent anyone from reaching in to grab your contents. The downside, however, is that the shape of the door can be limiting, especially when trying to receive packages.

    Outgoing mail can also be an issue with baffle doors. In most cases, you will have a clip where you can keep the mail stored inside, but you will have limited space. Alternatively, you can get a model that has two separate compartments for your mail. As long as the outgoing stuff is concealed, it should be safe from most prying eyes.

    Rear Access

    Although this is not a feature that comes with a lot of locking mailboxes, it can be quite handy in some situations. With these units, you can unlock the box from the back, which provides a couple of benefits. First, you can have more room to pull your contents out, since you don’t have to worry about the baffle or front door mechanism. Secondly, it allows you to access your mail more conveniently, as well as do so without drawing attention to the fact.

    For example, if you have a fence surrounding your house, having rear access can make your life so much easier. Rather than having to go out through the gate and come back, you can pull your mail out and be on your way.

    Final Verdict

    If you’re looking for the best locking mailbox, then look no further than the Mail Boss Package Master. We believe that this is the highest-quality offering out there, thanks to its larger size and durable construction.

    Even if you don’t receive packages that often, having a bigger box will enable you to have the option. Otherwise, if your box is too small, then you will have to figure something else out when the time comes. Overall, we really like everything that the Package Master has to offer, and we think that you will too.

    About the Author Todd Davis

    Leave a Comment: